5 Delectable Cookie Subscription Boxes to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth (Healthier options included)

The aroma of the freshly baked cookies wafting straight from the kitchen in a perfect box is a complete delight.

From classic chocolate chip to homemade butter cookies to stuffed cookies, we’ve got all the choices. It will seal the deal- subscription included, meaning a new delicious selection of cookies each month. Order for yourself or send a box as a gift!

These are rich, crispy, crumbly, and gooey. We have rounded up the five best cookie subscription boxes with a variety of tasty treats you must try.

  1. Southern Home Bakery

  2. The Very Best Cookie In the Whole Wide World

  3. Cookie Cottage

  4. Cookie NYC

  5. Coco Bakes

We also listed must-try bakery subscriptions with chocolates, cakes, pastries, bread, and other assortments. Make sure to check it out too!

Order your favorite to unbox happiness

1. Southern Home Bakery

Classic and delicious are the words to describe when enjoying cookies from Southern Home Bakery. The menu includes custom cookies, gourmet cookies, and bars.

Southern Home Bakery Cookies

They have an impressive variety of flavors for Gourmet cookies. You can shop chocolate chip gourmet cookie, pumpkin spice gourmet cookie, triple chocolate gourmet cookie, sugar sprinkled gourmet cookie, peanut butter cookie, oatmeal raisin gourmet cookie, and more.

What do you get with Southern Home Bakery Subscription?

Each cookie carton includes an assortment of 6 themed decorated sugar cookies for a variety of occasions, 4 gourmet cookies, and 4 packs of colorful dots. Indulge in the monthly sweet treat or send these as a gift.

The cookies are baked from scratch and hand-decorated according to the monthly theme. Make sure to order by the end of the month to receive the following month’s cookie box.

Choose Southern Home Bakery Subscription

Month to month- $39.99

3 month prepay- $107.97

6 month prepay- $203.94

12 month prepay- $383.88

For your monthly treat

Subscribe to Southern Home Bakery Now

2. The Very Best Cookie In The Whole Wide World

If you want or send the freshest cookies possible, nothing beats- The very best cookie in the whole wide world. As the name suggests, the cookies are delicious and freshly baked to order in Los Angeles.

Founder Kirstyn Shaw perfected the recipe for the chocolate chip cookie for probably a decade. In April 2020, the pandemic turned her side hobby into a thriving business.

The Very Best Cookies

With the highest-quality ingredients, there are a lot of flavors to discover in the cookie menu. Check out The O.G (also known as The Very Best Cookie In The Whole Wide World), I want it All, Triple Threat, The Buttah Pecan, The Cinner, The O.G (Gluten-Free), The Peanut Butteriest, and more tasteful delight.

What is special about the very best cookie? The cookie dough rests for a couple of days, which helps flavors to caramelize and develop. In it go chocolate chip and two different kinds of Belgian chocolate that make the whole cookie chocolatey. In the end, it is topped with sea salt to balance out all that chocolate.

It is $25 for a six-pack of cookies and is delivered locally and shipped nationwide.

For the ultimate chocolate chip cookie experience, bake the cookie dough in the comfort of your home. Get one dozen frozen cookie dough portions for $39. It includes parchment paper to bake on and sea salt to sprinkle on the cookies before you pop them in the oven.

For a whole new taste craving

Subscribe to The Very Best Cookie in the Whole Wide World Now

3. Cookie Cottage

Imagine receiving perfectly baked golden brown cookies straight from the oven, tempted?

Cookie Cottage offers something for everyone’s sweet tooth from classic chocolate cookies to nutty cookies. Baked with the finest ingredients and a treasured collection of recipes, you are in for a mouth-watering experience in every bite.

Based in Indiana, Cookie Cottage was founded by two sisters back in 1989 with the business based on family values and a commitment to the community and customers.

Cookie Cottage Varieties

Shop crispier cookies in flavors like chocolate, iced assortment, nutty cookies, and not-so-nutty that complements other ingredients. They also have a signature assortment box that features a variety of popular cookie flavors. Cookie Cottage costs $17 for one dozen in a neatly wrapped box.

Other than these, you can try cookie cakes, brownies (with a moist, fudge-like texture, these are a delightful treat), personalized cookies, and Georgie pies (like a cookie sandwich with 3 icing flavors and 22 cookie varieties to choose from).

What do you get with Cookie Cottage Subscription?

Cookie Cottage Subscription is everything that a cookie lover could want. Just pick the box size and choice of flavors to build your box. Select up to six different cookie flavors and enjoy the ultimate indulgent treat.

The cookies are made in a bakery that uses peanut butter and tree nuts and may contain traces of these ingredients.

A perfect mix of flavorful cookies

Subscribe to Cookie Cottage Now

4. Cookie NYC

Just like the name suggests, Cookie is your go-to place to relish the dough-ey goodness of the unbaked cookie. The coolest part is that you can shop the best cookie dough, cookies, cookie cakes, baking mixes and flour, and other baking kits.

What do we love about Cookie DŌ NYC?

Baking is a sort of therapy for many of us and there is something undeniable about the smooth, sweet, deliciousness that comes right from the mixing bowl. DŌ's spoon-ready deliciousness comes in more than 10 flavors.

The perfect recipes for the cookie flavors are prepared after a lot of research with tested and tried ingredients to suit all dietary restrictions.

Try dōlicious cookies baked from the freshly made dough. They have a variety of boxes such as build your cookie box, variety pack cookie box, classic chocolate chip cookie box, gluten-free cookie box, variety pack cookie box & edible cookie dough bundle, and more to choose from starting at $30.

What do you get with Cookie DŌ NYC Subscription?

Join The Cookie Dough Club and treat yourself with a monthly subscription of cookie doughliciousness delivered straight to your doorstep. You will receive new flavors and packs, free shipping, a package that includes 4 containers, a special surprise each month, and you get to try 2 classic flavors and 2 seasonal flavors. It costs $75 for a month-to-month cookie dough subscription. All these items may contain wheat, peanuts, nuts, eggs, milk, and soy.

Bake delicious and share with your loved ones

Subscribe to Cookie NYC Now

5. Coco Bakes

Who said cookies can't be healthy and delicious at the same time? Coco Bakes have exactly these with thin crispy edges and chewy middle. If you love cookies that look as good as they taste, you are in for a treat with Coco Bakes.

Coco Bakes Cookies

Being true to their founding spirit, they source the best quality, organic ingredients that bake gluten-free, dairy-free, and soy-free cookies.

Choose from flavors such as salted peanut butter chocolate chip cookies, snickerdoodle peanut butter cookies, and caramel cookies. Other than these, you can also shop for bars, bread, and cakes.

What do you get with Coco Bakes Cookie Subscription?

Coco Bakes cookie subscription offers three cookie flavors-

  • Salted Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie with flakey salt, coconut sugar, and peanut butter. The subscription starts at $21.60

  • Snickerdoodle Peanut Butter Cookie with just the right amount of sweetness

  • Caramel Cookies with deliciously amazing caramel in a chewy cookie (pack of 12)

Cookies are packed with ingredients such as organic peanut butter, organic coconut sugar, filtered water, organic chocolate chips, organic almond butter, vanilla extract, and more.

Healthy cookies for your sweet tooth

Subscribe to Coco Bakes Now